Subtraction


Up

 

PROGRESSION IN SUBTRACTION

As with addition, each stage shows progression from informal methods leading to a compact method. As children move to new stages the focus, in the first instance, should be on new method and layout, not on harder numbers.

For the majority of children, decomposition will be the compact method taught. For some children, who find this difficult, an alternative method is suggested. Children will have already encountered this method (complementary addition) as a strategy for mental calculation and will have recorded through informal jottings. It is also taught as part of the Springboard 5 programme.

DECOMPOSITION

Stage 1

58 – 32

50 – 30 = 20                                                                 Starting with what child can do mentally

  8 –  2 = 6                                                                    Start by dealing with the tens

20 + 6 =26                                                                    Child can use known subtraction facts

Stage 2  

 58 - 32                        152 - 41                                  This stage introduces:                        

                                                                                    Expanded layout based on partitioning

  50 + 8                            100 + 50 + 2                           Lining up vertically

- 30 + 2                        -           40 + 1                           Specific position of operation symbol

  20 + 6  =  26                   100 + 10 + 1   =  111               Lines to delineate answer

This stage involves calculations that do not require decomposition in order that children can focus on layout.

Initially start on with digits on right hand side to reflect mental strategies but then move to working with the least significant digit first in readiness for decomposition.

Stage 3

Children will need to become familiar with partitioning such as 84 = 70 + 14 in readiness for decomposition.              

  84 – 38                                                               362 – 48

  80 + 4                  70 + 14                                   300 + 60 + 2                 300 + 50 + 12

- 30 + 8               - 30 +   8                               -            40 + 8             -           40 +   8

                             40 +   6   =  46                                                          300 +  10 +   4  =  314  

Stage 3a  (for HTU ) 

                                                                                362 – 48   

                                                                                                           50     12

                                                                           300 + 60 + 2                         This stage introduces:

-           40 + 8                         A more compact stage

300 +  10 +   4   =  314

Stage 4   

84 – 38                                                             362 – 48

 7 8 14                                                                 3 5612                                     This stage introduces:

-  3  8                                                               -     4  8                                     Compact method           

   4  6                                                                  3  1  4                                    Language still reflects place value

Stages of partitioning should be introduced progressively when dealing with HTU

·          Partitioning tens into ones

·          Partitioning hundreds into tens

·          Partitioning hundreds and tens into tens and ones

An example of the latter would look like this at the various stages:

Stage 3

567 – 378

  500 + 60 + 7                 500 + 50 + 17                 400 + 150 + 17

- 300 + 70 + 8               - 300 + 70 +  8              - 300 +   70 +  8

                                                                          100 +   80  + 9   = 189

Stage 3a

  567 – 378

400       150       17

  500 +  60 +  7

- 300 +  70 +  8

  100 +  80  + 9   = 189

Stage 4  

567 – 378

  45 156 17

-  3   7  8

   1   8  9

The same stages can be applied as children are introduced to subtraction with larger number or decimals.

ALTERNATIVE TO DECOMPOSITION - COMPLEMENTARY ADDITION

Complementary addition (finding the difference by counting up) does not lead to a compact method. However, it has clear links to the mental methods and the work on empty number lines children will already have experienced. Modelling the stages of complementary addition on an empty number line will support children’s understanding.  

Stage 1  

74 - 27
7 4

-

2 7
1 3

to 30

4 0  to 70
1 4 to 74
4 7
Children could move on to doing this in fewer steps.
7 4

-

2 7
1 3 to 30
4 4 to 74
4 7

   7 4

- 2 7               

3     (è30)

  4 4    (è74)

  4 7 

Stage 2

Encourage children to estimate the size of the answer.  

326 – 178  Estimate: 150

   3 2 6

 - 1 7 8

       2        (è180)

     2 0    (è200)                     

1 0 0    (è300)

2 0    (è320)

        6    (è326)               

  1 4 8  

Moving on to:  

326 – 178

  3 2 6

- 1 7 8

2        (è180)

     2 0    (è200)                       

1 0 0    (è300)

     2 6    (è326)

   1 4 8 

Stage 3

Where children have sound knowledge of pairs that total 100, the number of steps can be reduced further.  

326 – 178

  3 2 6

- 1 7 8  

     2 2    (è200)          

  1 2 6    (è326)

  1 4 8 

 

Stage 4

Extend to bigger numbers and decimals

22.4 – 17.8    Estimate: 4

  2 2 . 4

- 1 7 . 8                            

 0 . 2  (è18)

4 . 0  (è22)

     0 . 4  (è22.4) 

     4 . 6  

Moving on to:  

22.4 – 17.8

  2 2 . 4

- 1 7 . 8                                                            

   0 . 2  (è18)

     4 . 4  (è22.4)         

     4 . 6